The story Mind & culture
Chaplin tips his hat. Now look at his shoes
An American poster for A Burlesque on Carmen shows Charlie Chaplin at his most courteous. Cover the bottom half for a moment. Then give him his feet back.
Published Updated
Berkshire Poster Company, Charlie Chaplin, c. 1916. Smithsonian National Portrait Gallery, NPG.84.114. Mark Gulezian/NPG, CC0.
One hand to his hat, jacket buttoned, a neat little knot under his chin. Cover the bottom half of this poster with your hand and Chaplin has manners to reassure a prospective mother-in-law. An acid-green ground and the long diagonal of the cane lend his entrance a certain poise.

Take your hand away. The trousers bag. The feet point in opposite directions. Just above the enormous letters spelling CHARLIE, toes poke through the fronts of the shoes. The salute gives nothing away.
On the way back up, there’s another detail at the waist. A triangle of striped waistcoat shows between the jacket edges. All around it there is either too much cloth or too little. That small waistcoat looks exactly right. It gives him every reason to go on behaving impeccably in the middle of the wreckage.
The National Portrait Gallery dates this Berkshire Poster Company lithograph to about 1916. It advertised A Burlesque on Carmen. No movement, no sound, no need to have seen the film. Someone tipped his hat and, in the time it took to look at his feet, you changed your mind about him.
