The guide Style & appearance

Scarf or coat collar: which catches your eye first?

The green knitted loop stays put under the chin. In a photograph from 1936, a patterned scarf claims an entire shoulder. It’s a decision you can make in the hall mirror.

Published Updated

Un homme porte un bonnet brun et un tube tricoté vert autour du cou, encadré par un vêtement sombre à capuche.

Wirsing Loop, Male Knitting, 2013, CC BY 2.0.

In Wirsing Loop, you see the green before you see the coat. The knitted tube ends where it begins, around the neck. No tail to tuck in, no fringe running down the chest. The dark hood frames it on either side. A brown hat does the rest. Thick knitting can hold the stage when the stage is this small.

Brown hat and green Wirsing Loop, 2013
Brown hat and green Wirsing Loop, 2013. Male Knitting, CC BY 2.0. Full photograph.

A Fortepan photograph from 1936 shows how differently a length of cloth can behave. The pattern travels round the neck and down one shoulder. Your eye goes along for the ride. Just below, in the middle of the picture, one large pointed collar tip appears quite undisturbed.

A woman in a coat holds a camera. A patterned scarf wraps around her neck and falls over the shoulder on the right of the image; a collar point remains visible in the middle.
The patterned ends fall over one shoulder while a large collar point keeps its place in the middle.FOTO:FORTEPAN / Jankovszky György, 1936, photo 19054 (former ID 11328). CC BY-SA 3.0. Full photograph, uncropped.

That’s the detail I’d borrow. If the collar was part of the reason you bought the coat, let it show. Wind the scarf, throw both ends to one side and see how much of the other lapel you have left. If what you like is the knitting, tuck in the ends and let the edges of the coat outline the shape.