The guide Style & appearance

Pointed shoes: where do your toes go?

Published Updated

Deux richelieus dorés à lacets de ruban crème. Celui de devant montre le bout effilé, celui du fond son profil légèrement relevé.

Brooklyn Museum Costume Collection at The Metropolitan Museum of Art. Gift of the Brooklyn Museum, 2009. Gift of Marion Fisher, 1952. CC0.

Around 1891 a New York store sold these gold kidskin Oxfords with enormous cream ribbons. Looking is quite enough with this pair. With the next one it’s worth looking underneath too.

The ribbon makes a big, slightly crooked bow. Below it the gold leather runs perfectly straight to the point. The Met has a quieter piece of information than the colour. Combine the address of Alfred J. Cammeyer’s store on the label with the shoe’s style and the pair can be dated to 1889–93. Gold kidskin was an unusual choice for an evening shoe at the time.

Two gold lace-up oxfords with cream ribbon bows. The nearer shoe shows the tapered toe, the other its slightly upturned profile.
Evening oxfords sold by Alfred J. Cammeyer, about 1891. The cream ribbon sits loose above the tapered toe in front. Behind it is the same toe in profile. Brooklyn Museum Costume Collection at The Metropolitan Museum of Art. Gift of the Brooklyn Museum, 2009. Gift of Marion Fisher, 1952. Public domain (CC0). The pair in The Met collection.

The shoe at the back reveals what the one in front can’t. Seen from the side, the tip turns up just enough for a sliver of light to get underneath. To buy a pointed pair today, I’d want a third, distinctly less photogenic view. I’d turn the shoe over.

A pencil and a little toe

When even a shoe sold as wide pinches your little toe, the podiatry team at Guy’s and St Thomas’ suggests a simple check. Hold the sole towards you and line up a pencil with the centre of the heel. Follow the outside edge towards the front. If it curves sharply in by your little toe, try a shoe with a straighter outside edge.

Length is a separate matter. Standing up, allow about a centimetre beyond your longest toe. You can have that space at the front and still need more room at the side. Walk a few steps in your usual socks. And if the pointed pair fits, have it. Personally, I’d look for the ribbon too.