The story Mind & culture

Does a shaved head look more masculine? Four portraits put it to the test

Researchers took the hair off four men in photographs. Somehow, in the eyes of the people looking, the men grew taller too.

Published Updated

A man with a shaved head in a navy blue jacket, against an urban stone backdrop.

Four portraits, two versions of each. In one set the men have hair. In the other, someone has taken it off on a computer. Had you taken part in Albert Mannes’s experiment, you would have seen just one of the eight pictures. Among other things, you’d have been asked how tall you thought the man was. All you’d have to go on was his head.

Same man, imaginary inches

In the retouched pictures, the men gain just over four-fifths of an inch in the participants’ estimates. They look stronger, too. But watch what happens when the question changes from masculinity to attractiveness.

Average ratings for the same four men
What people ratedWith hairDigitally shaved
Masculinity (out of 9)5.646.19
Attractiveness (out of 9)5.925.41
Leadership potential (out of 7)4.804.87

Each participant saw just one picture. These averages compare the answers of 174 people shown the men with hair and 170 shown the retouched portraits. Masculinity goes up, attractiveness goes down. On leadership potential, the gap of seven hundredths of a point was not statistically significant. A curious set of instructions for anyone considering a shave before a first date or a job interview. Figures from Albert Mannes, Study 2, Table 2.

It pays to look at the questions. One way the study measured perceived masculinity was to have people place a man somewhere between weak and strong. Had your answer been “tender”, “very funny” or “depends who he’s with”, there was no box for it. A scale is good at picking up the things someone thought to put on it.

What four portraits leave out

The 344 responses retained for this experiment concerned four white men, and the participants were recruited in the United States. Nobody heard the men speak, saw them settle an argument or asked them to lift a piano. The four men in this experiment had already featured among the portraits rated in the first. In the third, participants read a written description in which only the hair changed. Nobody met anyone in those either. Mannes discusses how much to read into the findings in his interview with Wharton.

Next time a headline promises you more masculinity in five minutes at the sink, remember the man who grew taller in his photograph. All that changed was somebody else’s estimate.