The story Mind & culture

Place Vendôme, 1871: what comes into view when the column falls

The Paris Commune brought down the Vendôme Column on 16 May 1871. In two photographs at the Musée Carnavalet, its disappearance brings a different piece of Paris into view.

Published Updated

Sur la place Vendôme, un fût sombre monte hors du cadre à droite, devant une façade à lucarnes. Un échafaudage entoure le socle.

Auguste Bruno Braquehais, Paris Musées / Musée Carnavalet, PH4142-191. CC0.

Two riders in shadow at the foot of the first photograph. Above them, little dormer windows along a Paris roof, then a great dark bar cutting through the picture on the right. The Vendôme Column is so tall that the top is missing from the print. Scaffolding surrounds its base. If you had to draw the façade behind it now, what would you put in the middle?

Before 16 May 1871: two riders at the bottom and the column shaft rising out of the frame on the right.
Place Vendôme before the column came down. Print attributed to Auguste Bruno Braquehais. Musée Carnavalet, PH4142-190. CC0 Paris Musées / Musée Carnavalet – Histoire de Paris.

Here is the second print. The pedestal stands and pale sections of the column lie across the square. More of the picture belongs to the sky. Behind the scaffolding, two slopes of stone meet above the windows. There is a triangular pediment in the middle of the façade.

After the column fell, sections lie to the left of the pedestal. Behind the scaffolding, a triangular pediment is visible.
After 16 May 1871. Auguste Bruno Braquehais. Musée Carnavalet, PH4142-191. CC0 Paris Musées / Musée Carnavalet – Histoire de Paris. Collection record and full-size photograph.

Go back to the first photograph. You can now find a piece of that triangle on either side of the shaft. It took the whole triangle to make you want to look for the pieces. On your first pass those two riders made excellent accomplices. While you were looking at them, the scenery kept its secret.

The museum dates the prints to either side of 16 May 1871. It attributes the first to Auguste Bruno Braquehais and gives his name as photographer on the second. The moment of the fall escapes both pictures. In its place is something a film of the toppling might never have made us notice: that perfectly ordinary roof, suddenly restored to the square.