The story Mind & culture

Black Converse or black dress shoes? Look at the stitching and the broguing

Published Updated

Paire de Converse All Star de 1995, toile sombre, coutures et lacets clairs, gomme crème. Wien Museum M 20150. Photo TimTom, CC BY 4.0.

TimTom / Wien Museum, M 20150, CC BY 4.0.

A pair of 1995 Converse and a pair of 1920s town shoes share a museum in Vienna. When it comes to deciding which to wear out, the word “black” is remarkably little help.

A shoelace has escaped. Against the grey background of the Wien Museum’s photograph, it looks like a chalk line that wandered off. The rest of the Converse knows precisely where it is going. Two rows of pale stitching run beside the lacing, round the ankle and across the black canvas. Below, the colours swap jobs. Two dark bands travel along the cream rubber.

1995 Converse All Stars, dark canvas, pale laces and cream rubber edging
1995 Converse All Stars, dark canvas, pale laces and cream rubber edging. TimTom, Wien Museum, M 20150, CC BY 4.0.

Vienna’s Schwarz chapter also makes room for the black Oxford of business and evening wear. This second pair from the museum’s collection dates to 1920–30. Perforations pick out a line behind the toe and another round the heel. Take a step back. The pattern melts into the dark surface. With the Converse, you could cross the room and still make out the seams.

Two black lace-up shoes seen from above, with one shown in profile beside them. A row of perforations crosses each toe cap.
A period example from the Wien Museum collection, dated 1920–1930. A row of perforations runs behind each toe cap. In profile, the same detail appears above the heel. Unknown maker, Herrenhalbschuhe, 1920–1930. Wien Museum, inv. M 15168. Photograph by Andrea Schmidt. CC BY 4.0 Wien Museum. Collection record.

Choose a pair for dark trousers and that difference will do more to your silhouette than the colour printed on the box. Dark leather continues the line of the leg. Pale rubber draws a line along the floor and makes the shoe conspicuous again. It depends whether you’d like anyone to notice it.

There is a star, of course, on the inside of the farther Converse. But the most relaxed thing in this rather precisely drawn pair belongs to the lace. It’s loosened its tie already. Cover photograph licence.